April-2017 Active vs Passive Investing: Large Cap Equity Mutual Funds

I would like to compare actively managed mutual funds with a set of indices every quarter to find out how effectively fund managers are able to beat benchmarks after expenses. I consider large cap mutual funds in this post as an update to the previous report published in Dec. 2016.

There is a lot of speculation about the disappearance of “alpha” from actively managed mutual funds. For someone who understands portfolio management, alpha  refers to this:

If you can recall 11th standard geometry, alpha is the intercept and beta the slope. In other words, if the index return equalled the return from a risk-free instrument (like a FD), then alpha is the extra return that the fund manager produced.

When you hear someone say, “studies show that alpha is decreasing”, then the alpha they refer to is calculated as shown above.

However, for the common man, alpha is just fund return minus the index return. If the Sensex total returns index (dividends reinvested) gave 10% over the last year and my fund gave 11% (always after expenses), the alpha or the outperformance I perceive is 1%.

If Sensex gave -5% and my fund is -4%, the perceived outperformance is the same.

The standard alpha calculation is arbitrary due to the need for setting a risk-free return. Then, there is an incorrect underlying assumption involved that returns fall on a bell curve. Therefore, I will prefer not to take such studies seriously and simply focus on plan outperformance. Of course, I cannot then discuss how well the fund manager managed risk, that is okay for a start.

Also, I compare the bare index (no expenses are factored in the index return – which is not practical) and I use only regular funds for comparison. While direct funds (no commissions) will improve the active fund performance a bit, it is better to tilt the scale in favour of the indices, to begin with, and then check for the outperformance.

The passive “funds” considered are:

1 BSE Large Cap Total Returns Index (TRI)

2 Nifty 50 TRI

3 Nifty 50 Value 20: the 20 most liquid value blue chip stocks selected from the Nifty 50 index. Read more: Nifty50 Value 20 Index (NV20) as a mutual fund benchmark

4 Nifty Quality 30: 30 stocks that show signs of a “durable business model”. A quality score is assigned after considering ROE, Debt/Equity and Profit After Tax for the last three financial years. Read more: Nifty Strategy Indices as Mutual Fund Benchmarks

5 Nifty Low Volatility: A portfolio of 50 stocks that has the least volatility among all the stocks listed on the NSE. This is referred to as a smart beta strategy. Read more: Nifty Low Volatility 50: A Benchmark Index to watch out for.

One can debate if the last two indices are truly “large cap”, but both of them are less volatile than the Nifty 50. So I believe the comparison is justified.

6. This time I have also added the BSE Balanced Index.

This has

70% of S&P BSE AllCap Index (total returns index) and

30% of S&P BSE  India Bond Index.

The BSE Allcap index has about 70% large cap allocation, 15% mid-cap and 15% small-cap. This I believe represents a typical portfolio alignment of most equity-oriented balanced funds. The 70% allocation to this equity index also reflects the typical asset allocation of such funds.

The BSE Indian Bond Index is a composite bond index that consists of both government and corporate bonds with a maturity duration that is neither too small or nor too long. I think this is a suitable candidate for the fixed income portfolio.

Active Large Cap funds vs BSE Large Cap TRI

Active Large Cap funds vs Nifty TRI

Active Large Cap funds vs Nifty Low Volatility

Active Large Cap funds vs Nifty 50 Value 20

Active Large Cap funds vs Nifty Quality 30

Active Large Cap funds vs BSE Balanced TRI

The Nifty Next 50 is the most promising index fund that I have seen, but that is strictly not a large cap index. The next promising index is the Nifty Low Volatility 50 (although not strictly large cap).

Someone, please make an index fund (not ETF) based on this already!

I think most fund managers easily manage to beat other standard large cap indices.

So what are your thoughts about this data?

New Delhi DIY Investor Workshop April 23rd 2017

Register for the New Delhi DIY Investor Workshop April 23rd 2017

You Can Be Rich Too With Goal-Based Investing

is my book with PV Subramanyam. It is a jargon-free non-technical introduction to managing your money and comes with nine online calculators and detailed guides to choose equity and debt mutual funds.

A very concise and practical read. No nonsense advice to personal finance.

The best book ever on Financial Freedom Planning. Go get it now!

Your first investment should be buying this book

The (nine online) calculators are really awesome and will give you all possible insights

Thank you, readers, for your generous support and patronage.

Amazon Hardcover Rs. 317  21% OFF

Kindle at Amazon.in (Rs. 244.30)

Google Play Store (Rs. 244.30)

Infibeam Rs. 315 

If you use a mobikwik wallet, and purchase via infibeam, you can get up to 100% cashback!!

  • Ask the right questions about money
  • get simple solutions
  • Define your goals clearly with worksheets
  • Calculate the correct asset allocation for each goal.
  • Find out how much insurance cover you need, and how much you need to invest with nine online calculator modules
  • Learn to choose mutual funds qualitatively and quantitatively.

More information is available here: A Beginner’s Guide To Make Your Money Dreams Come True!

What Readers Say

Also Available At

Bookadda Rs. 371. Flipkart Rs. 359

Amazon.com ($ 3.70 or Rs. 267)

Google Play Store (Rs. 244.30)

Create a "from start to finish" financial plan with this free robo advisory software template


Free Apps for your Android Phone

Install Financial Freedom App! (Google Play Store)


Install Freefincal Retirement Planner App! (Google Play Store)


Find out if you have enough to say "FU" to your employer (Google Play Store)


About Freefincal

Freefincal has open-source, comprehensive Excel spreadsheets, tools, analysis and unbiased, conflict of interest-free commentary on different aspects of personal finance and investing. If you find the content useful, please consider supporting us by (1) sharing our articles and (2) disabling ad-blockers for our site if you are using one. We do not accept sponsored posts, links or guest posts request from content writers and agencies.

Blog Comment Policy

Your thoughts are vital to the health of this blog and are the driving force behind the analysis and calculators that you see here. We welcome criticism and differing opinions. I will do my very best to respond to all comments asap. Please do not include hyperlinks or email ids in the comment body. Such comments will be moderated and I reserve the right to delete the entire comment or remove the links before approving them.

4 thoughts on “April-2017 Active vs Passive Investing: Large Cap Equity Mutual Funds

  1. Yes, funds are largely beating the indices. However, the alpha is REDUCING if not DISAPPEARING. Meaning, previously actively managed funds used to beat the indices by 9-10% which now in general is reduced to around 4-5% (% mentioned only for example)

    The amount of money coming to equity market will make the overall market more efficient in terms of price discoveries and thereby reduction in outperformance. Many fund managers are acknowledging the difficulties in generating alpha.

    At any given point of time there will be funds which will beat the indices. Consistency going forward is the question.

    1. Not interested in speculation. I prefer hard facts. Finding a fund that beats standard indices is simply too easy today. When the facts change, choices will change.

  2. I’ve been following this blog for almost couple of years now, but this my first comment …

    From the perspective of an investor who is currently investing in large cap MFs and thinking about index investing, it is useful to know the performance of index vs actively managed MFs. One additional thing that would be useful – if it is possible – would be to know the degree of outperformance. For instance, what’s the annual %age of subperformance compared to the actively managed funds that have outperformed it ?

  3. Are you referring to this fund – “ICICI Prudential Nifty Next 50 Index Fund” ? Believe this is a fund and not an ETF. The returns from this are too good to be true for an index in India.

Do let us know what you think about the article