Excel’s IRR and XIRR functions are often used to calculate the rate of investment returns. In this post, let us discuss the limitations of XIRR and IRR functions.
Credit: This discussion is inspired by financial planner Mr. Hari who posted a video describing the limitations of IRR and XIRR on my XIRR calculator page. The video (a must watch for finance professionals) is linked below.
A couple of weeks ago, when the Chit fund returns calculator was published, I had mentioned that, for any investment, if the amount invested is less than the amount received, it might not be possible to calculate the rate of return.
Excels XIRR and IRR functions, or any other code for that matter, cannot handle such situations because there is more than one rate of return possible!
In order to understand what this means, let us review some basic definitions.
Cash flow: For the purposes of this post, we define cash flow as receipts – payments.
So if you make a profit in any investment the cash flow is positive and if you incur a loss, the cash flow is negative.
IRR: IRR or internal rate of return is a function in Excel used to calculate the return for any periodic cash flow entries. For example, if you pay insurance premium for 12 months and receive some cash back in the 13^{th} month, you could calculate the monthly IRR and then convert to a CAGR (compounded annual growth rate)
XIRR: If the cash flow entries are not periodic, then XIRR may be used to compute CAGR straightaway using the dates of payments and receipts.
Both IRR and XIRR are approximation methods (we will see why this is necessary below). Therefore, you may have to help them out buy entering a guess for the return.
Let us start a simple situation.
Lump sum investment
Suppose I invest Rs. 100 for 5 years and get Rs. 150 at the end of 5 years, what is the rate of return?
To determine this, we calculate
Compound Interest Formula
Here, rate is the rate of return we need to calculate. First, we rewrite
That is, we can pull the rate to one side of the equation.
When this is possible, we can always determine the rate uniquely. That is, there will only be one answer.
SIP investment
Suppose I run a monthly SIP of Rs. 1000 for 5 years and obtain a corpus of say, Rs. 70,000, what is the rate of return?
In this case, the formula gets a bit complicated!
Here, 12000 is the annual investment. Unfortunately, in this case the rate cannot be pulled to one side of the equation.
- Therefore, we have to estimate the rate of returns and cannot determine it as mentioned in my post on generating MF account statement with returns
- Therefore, we need to estimate the returns from a SIP as mentioned in post on SIP account statement from NAV history
To do this, let us first denote
Here f(rate) simply means a quantity which depends on the rate.
We can now write the SIP formula as
C - f(rate) =0
Here C is the corpus accumulated (Rs. 70, 000 in our example). Now we start guessing the rate.
- If our guess is incorrect, C - f(rate) ≠ 0
- If our guess if correct, C - f(rate) =0
Suppose I draw a graph between C - f(rate) versus all possible reasonable for the rate (say between -100% and +100%) then we might get something like this.
Notice that curve cuts the x-axis at only point. At this point the value of the y-axis is zero (that is C - f(rate) =0).
The corresponding value of the x-axis is the rate of return.
While this is a simple graphical way of calculating the return, there are many mathematical methods to calculate return. Excel’s IRR and XIRR uses a method known as Newton –Raphson method. Here is an excellent review on the subject (strongly recommend resource for all finance professionals)
Calculating rate using such methods work fine, provided the cash flow is positive. That is receipts should be greater than payments.
When the cash flow becomes negative (loss in investment) and in particular a large negative number (huge loss), the plot between C - f(rate) versus rate may look like this.
Notice that the curve intersects the x-axis at three points. This means that there are 3 solutions. That is three different rates correspond to our cash flow entries.
Many find this impossible to believe. Unfortunately, this is not only possible but also quite natural.
If we knew what the three solutions are, we could check them using Excels XNPV function. This function returns a value of zero if the right rate of return is chosen. XPNV will be zero for all possible solutions!
Next week I will post an Excel tool by which we can determine all possible solutions for a given cash flow statement.
Video mentioned above
A look at Excel's XIRR function
If you read the comments below the video, you may notice that I had an interesting discussion with the author.
Bottomline:
- When the investment loss is huge, multiple rate of returns is possible.
- All such solutions are equally correct
- You cannot pick and choose a solution that you like!
- Typically, for such situations, IRR and XIRR will return an error.
- An error is better because, for some situations IRR and XIRR can produce one of the many possible solutions! This is unfortunate because the user believes the answer without realizing that the result is wrong!
The solution: Do not lose money! That way the cash flow is positive and the return will always be unique. Excels IRR and XIRR are then dependable!
Your view: Do spare a moment to let me know if you were able to follow the discussion. What do you make out of all this? If you can add to this discussion in any way, please let me know.
Get GameChanger (my second book) + Pranav's Travel Training Kit GameChanger (hardcopy is now available for ₹279 (249 +30 for shipping) and the Travel Training Kit is available for immediate download for ₹150.
Register for the Kolkata DIY Investor meet: May 28th2017
Get free, yet comprehensive calculators, tools and analysis delivered to your mailbox! Subscribe to get posts via email Your subscription is successful if you are directed to the "Welcome Page"
Install Financial Freedom App! (Google Play Store)
Install Freefincal Retirement Planner App! (Google Play Store)
Find out if you have enough to say "FU" to your employer (Google Play Store)
Buy our New Book!You Can Be Rich With Goal-based Investing A book by P V Subramanyam (subramoney.com) & M Pattabiraman. Read more about the book and pre-order now! |
Sir, Thank you very much. Of course it's too technical. Hence wait for your next post.:)
"Next week I will post an Excel tool by which we can determine all possible solutions for a given cash flow statement."
Thanks Hari. We could only determine all possible solutions. Does not mean it would be helpful to us 🙂
Sir, Thank you very much. Of course it's too technical. Hence wait for your next post.:)
"Next week I will post an Excel tool by which we can determine all possible solutions for a given cash flow statement."
Thanks Hari. We could only determine all possible solutions. Does not mean it would be helpful to us 🙂
Dear Pattu, Thanks for sharing. I was also finding it tough to calculate real return if losses are huge. 🙂
I'll wait for your next post.
Thanks
Ashal
LOL. Good one Ashal! 'Real return' can be negative even for positive cash flows 🙂
Dear Pattu, Thanks for sharing. I was also finding it tough to calculate real return if losses are huge. 🙂
I'll wait for your next post.
Thanks
Ashal
LOL. Good one Ashal! 'Real return' can be negative even for positive cash flows 🙂
Dear Pattu, many thanks for sharing
I want to know how we can calculate composite XIRR and CAGR for a portfolio.
Let say, I have a portfolio consisting of three different funds with uneven inflows and outflows.
I find out XIRR and CAGR for all three funds separately. How these individual returns will be composite to show a return (XIRR and CAGR) on Portfolio.
Hi Gaurav, There are two ways one can do it.
(1) Fund A gives 10% return and constitutes 40% of investment value
fund B 11% return and 30% weight
fund C 12% return and 30 weight
So net XIRR is = 10%*0.4+11%*0.3+12%*0.3
This is known as a weighted sum
(2) The other way is to integrate the cash flow for all funds get a single XIRR. This is what I do for my NPS account.
if you send me a file with sample data, I can show you how to put it together.
Keep visiting.
Dear Pattu, many thanks for sharing
I want to know how we can calculate composite XIRR and CAGR for a portfolio.
Let say, I have a portfolio consisting of three different funds with uneven inflows and outflows.
I find out XIRR and CAGR for all three funds separately. How these individual returns will be composite to show a return (XIRR and CAGR) on Portfolio.
Hi Gaurav, There are two ways one can do it.
(1) Fund A gives 10% return and constitutes 40% of investment value
fund B 11% return and 30% weight
fund C 12% return and 30 weight
So net XIRR is = 10%*0.4+11%*0.3+12%*0.3
This is known as a weighted sum
(2) The other way is to integrate the cash flow for all funds get a single XIRR. This is what I do for my NPS account.
if you send me a file with sample data, I can show you how to put it together.
Keep visiting.
Dear Pattu,
I think the second way is the correct method to find out exact return on a portfolio. In most of the cases the investment date or withdrawal date of various assets is different. Then how we can get actual return via using simple weighted average method.
Please provide you e-mail id so that I can send you a sample excel sheet which comprises of three funds having different inflows & outflows and have different dates of contribution and withdrawal.
Dear Pattu,
I think the second way is the correct method to find out exact return on a portfolio. In most of the cases the investment date or withdrawal date of various assets is different. Then how we can get actual return via using simple weighted average method.
Please provide you e-mail id so that I can send you a sample excel sheet which comprises of three funds having different inflows & outflows and have different dates of contribution and withdrawal.
Finally, an explanation of the "XIRR bug". You might be the only one to have explained it.
Now I can sleep again.
Thanks
Thanks. There are two issues:
1> Multiple solutions which make XIRR return an error. this is not a bug.
2> incorrect convergence. This is a bug.
I will soon be post a XIRR solution validator. Stay tuned!
Finally, an explanation of the "XIRR bug". You might be the only one to have explained it.
Now I can sleep again.
Thanks
Thanks. There are two issues:
1> Multiple solutions which make XIRR return an error. this is not a bug.
2> incorrect convergence. This is a bug.
I will soon be post a XIRR solution validator. Stay tuned!
sir, send me your file.
Sent to your email Email.
http://freefincal.com/can-help-test-mutual-fund-financial-goal-tracker/
sir, send me your file.
Sent to your email Email.
http://freefincal.com/can-help-test-mutual-fund-financial-goal-tracker/