Star Health Comprehensive Insurance vs Religare Care Comprehensive Insurance

Last week I had compared Apollo Munich Optima Restore Benefit vs Max Bupa Re-fill Benefit. This week we shall continue our policy wordings walk-through with a discussion on some lesser-known features of Star Health Comprehensive Insurance policy and Religare Care Comprehensive Insurance policy. The main aim of these posts is to emphasise the importance of policy wordings or terms and conditions before buying the policy. Typically investors read these documents only when their claim is denied and wish to make a complaint to IRDA often after being emotionally spurred on by social media.

I neither have the time nor the inclination to publish a feature-by-feature comparison and will only talk about sentences that catch my eye. After publishing ₹e-Assemble step 4: How to choose a suitable health insurance policy, I have received several requests from readers asking for my help in choosing a health policy for them. Kindly note that I am not a health insurance professional and again do not have the time or inclination to help with such personal queries I am sorry but I do not enjoy offering personalised advice. I am open to answering generic questions on policy features. If you want help in choosing policies please consult a professional. It is quite easy for me tie up with insurance portal in the name of “helping” readers (get offers each week). I will not because it even if I do it without profit, it will diminish my ability to think straight and talk freely. As it is, I have enough trouble thinking, let alone straight.

First, let us consider the perks of Star Health and Religare Health and compare them Apollo Munich and Max Bupa.

1 No claims bonus

Apollo Munich has a multiplier option where the bonus increases by 50% of the sum insured (SI) the year after there is no claim but decreases by the same amount the year after a claim. The maximum allowed increase is 100% of the SI. Star Health Comprehensive Insurance has an identical feature but it is called a cumulative bonus. That is an amusing name for something can decrease!!

Star Health Insurance Cumulative Bonus and Automatic Restoration policy terms

Religare has  a 10% no claims bonus that decreases by the same amount in the year following a claim. The ceiling is also 50% of the SI. There are other bonus options that can be purchased for extra premium. I do not cover them here.

( Max Bupa no decreasing bonus) vs (Apollo Munich & Start Health & Star Health: decreasing bonus)

Key difference: Max Bupa is better on this count because it offers 20% no claim bonus for each claim free year subject to a maximum of 100% of the SI. This is better than a bonus that decreases upon a claim as fast as it is given.

2 Restoration of sum insured in a policy year upon a claim

Remember: This is not as important as no claims bonus.

The “Automatic Restoration of Sum Insured” of Star Insurance is identical to the Apollo Munich Restore benefit. This is the Star Health Comprehensive cover policy wordings

Apollo Munich Optima Restore Benefit Illustration

Religare Insurance has an automatic recharge option which is essentially identical to both Apollo Munich restore benefit and Star Health “Automatic Restoration of Sum Insured. This is the Religare Insurance Comprehensive cover policy wordings

Religare Health Insurance Automatic Recharge
Star Health Automatic Recharge Wordings

Note: I am deliberately not cutting and pasting text from the policy wordings and inserting snapshots. There is no fun in filling a post verbatim with information that you can read elsewhere.

Don’t spend too much time worrying about this feature it is not important. For the record:

Max Bupa refill is different from the restore options of Apollo Munich, Religare Health and Star Health.

Max Bupa Health Companion Re-fill Benefit illustration

Max Bupa has a bit of an edge here as well because the re-fill works for partial exhaustion of claims. In addition, its no claims bonuses do not decrease as mentioned above. So just on these two features alone, I would say it is better.

3 The difference between outpatient coverage and Daycare coverage

It is important to consider the difference between these two features of an insurance policy. Many people seem to think they both mean the same. In fact, they are exclusive to each other. If you are a doctor please excuse me for the following. I just made it up.

If you have abdominal discomfort plus indigestion and go to the doctor for treatment, you an outpatient. The doctor gives you a prescription and wants you to come back after two weeks. You go again, again as an outpatient. She then orders an ultrasound of your tummy. This is a diagnostic test done in a lab upon a doctors recommendation.

You go see the doctor again and she gives you the bad news: fluid collection in your abdomen which has to be drained out. In the old days, this would have required an overnight hospital stay, but you could now go home the same day.

So you sign up for a “Pancreatic pseudocyst EUS & drainage”. This is a daycare procedure and it is done on a doctors recommendation.

Now, no insurer will cover you for the ultrasound as it is a diagnostic procedure (and you are not admitted in a hosptital). Even if you get admitted only for the ultrasound, they will not cover you.

The “Pancreatic pseudocyst EUS & drainage” is an allowed daycare procedure. That is, you will be admitted as an in-patient who will be dischared the same day. So that will be covered by most insurers even PSUs who do not make a song and dance about daycare treatment as much as the privates do.

The visits you made to the doctor count as out-patient consultation. Some policies cover this. Apollo Munich does not, Max Bupa does not. Religare offers this as an add-on. Star Health provides this.

Star Health offers this:

Outpatient consultation (other than Dental and Ophthalmic treatment) Minimum Rs. 1,200/- Maximum Rs.3,300/- based on the sum insured.  Outpatient Dental and Ophthalmic treatment Minimum Rs. 5,000/- Maximum Rs.10,000/- based on the sum insured

But

Claims of Out Patient Consultations / treatments will be settled on a reimbursement basis on production of cash receipts.

But

Expenses of Medical Consultations as an Out Patient incurred in a Network Hospital for other than Dental and Ophthalmic treatments, up to the limits mentioned in the schedule of benefits with a limit of Rs.300/- per consultation. Payment under this benefit G does not form part of Sum Insured, and payable while the policy is in force.

With:

Star Health Insurance out patient consultation benefits

You will probably not agree with me, but in my opinion, this feature is a waste of time and money. Excuse me, I would prefer my nice little doctor in a nice little clinic and will not go to a network hospital to see an unknown doctor to save some money. Outpatient coverage is not the core feature of a health insurance policy and should be disregarded while buying a policy.

Daycare treatment, on the other hand, is crucial and the exclusions in this section should be carefully understood. Many insurers clearly list the daycare procedures allowed. Some simply state some example and say they will support daycare coverage provided

  • The treatment is undertaken under General or Local Anesthesia in a hospital/day care centrein less than 24 hours because of technological advancement and which would have otherwise required a hospitalisation of more than 24 hours

As far as my understanding goes, this is good enough as long as there are not any important daycare exclusions. I could not find any serious issues with the daycare wordings of all four policies.

4 Co-payment

This is a cost-sharing arrangement in which you pay 10% or 20% of the hospital costs and the insurer pays the rest (up to the sum insured which is independent).This co-pay will apply to each claim made.

Apollo Munich Optima Restore —> no co-pay

Religare Care Heath Insurance —> 20% co-pay if age of entry is 61 or above. Option to take 20% co-pay (lower premium) if person reason 61 during coverage.

Max Bupa Companion —-> Optional 20%

Star Health Comprehensive Insurance —–> 10% co-pay for persons aged above 60 (fresh or renewal)

Considering its cover is already pricey (see below) Star Health is not attractive on this count. It is good to have optional co-pay after 60 for people who buy young. After 60, we can reduce the premium if we wish to. A choice is always good compared to a strict copay or no-copay feature.

5 Feature Differences

This is a snapshot of a comparison made with policybaazaar (this is a direct comparison link). This only shows some features. So do not base your decision only on these. For example, co-ayment differences and the inpatient consultation coverage of Star Health is not considered below.

Feature comparison of Star Health Comprehensive Insurance, Apollo Munich Optima Restore, Religare Care Health Insurance and MAx Bupa Health Companion

Notice the difference in costs vs features. Star health offer inpatient consultation (not shown above), and maternity benefits. This could lead to an increase in costs. I would discard these features.

Although Max Bupa has a lower coverage network, as long as it is valid near hospitals and home and work, I think has some good features – no reducing bonus, lower pe-existing disease waiting period (among these), better ambulance coverage.

Although Religare has lower costs, its bonus comes with a reduction on the claim. My idea has been to offer a way to compare and not make an exact comparison. I hope this series of posts will aid selection from at least these insurers. Will take up Sundaram and one more company next week.

logos of Star Health, Apollo Munich, Religare Health and Max Bupa


Do check out my books

You can be rich 243x300 - Star Health Comprehensive Insurance vs Religare Care Comprehensive InsuranceYou Can Be Rich Too with Goal-Based Investing, my first book is now available at a 35% discount for Rs. 258. It comes with nine online calculators. Get it now.
Cover-pinkGamechanger, my second book is now only Rs 149 (25% off).  Get it or gift it to a young earner 
Travel-Training-Kit-CoverThe ultimate guide to travel by Pranav Surya is a deep dive analysis into vacation planning, finding cheap flights, budget accommodation, what to do when travelling, how travelling slowly is better financially and psychologically with links to the web pages and hand-holding at every step.  Get the pdf for ₹199 (instant download)

Use this form to ask Questions or reg. the robo template ONLY (For comments/opinions, use the form at the bottom)

And I will respond to them in the next few days. I welcome tough questions. Please do not ask for investment advice. Before asking, please search the site if the issue has already been discussed. Thank you.  PLEASE DO NOT POST COMMENTS WITH THIS FORM it is for questions only.

Create a "from start to finish" financial plan with this free robo advisory software template


Free Apps for your Android Phone

Install Financial Freedom App! (Google Play Store)
Install Freefincal Retirement Planner App! (Google Play Store)
Find out if you have enough to say "FU" to your employer (Google Play Store)

About Freefincal

Freefincal has open-source, comprehensive Excel spreadsheets, tools, analysis and unbiased, conflict of interest-free commentary on different aspects of personal finance and investing. If you find the content useful, please consider supporting us by (1) sharing our articles and (2) disabling ad-blockers for our site if you are using one. We do not accept sponsored posts, links or guest posts request from content writers and agencies.

Blog Comment Policy

Your thoughts are vital to the health of this blog and are the driving force behind the analysis and calculators that you see here. We welcome criticism and differing opinions. I will do my very best to respond to all comments asap. Please do not include hyperlinks or email ids in the comment body. Such comments will be moderated and I reserve the right to delete the entire comment or remove the links before approving them.

6 thoughts on “Star Health Comprehensive Insurance vs Religare Care Comprehensive Insurance

  1. I checked the STAR website for copay. It is as below.
    >> 10% of each and every claim for persons above 60 years at entry level and their subsequent renewals. <<
    I understood this as: "those who buy policy (and subsequent renewal) on or after 60 will have mandatory copay of 10%. Those who buy young (< 60) and continue and pass through 60 years will not have to.

    1. “Co-payment: This policy is subject to co-payment of 10% of each and every claim amount for fresh as well as renewal policies for insured persons
      whose age at the time of proposing this insurance policy is above 60 years. ” Page 12 of the policy wordings

      Each time you renew, you make a fresh proposal is what I would like to understand it as. Please write to insurer for confirmation (hopefully someone who understood your question will answer!)

  2. Hello Pattu sir,

    Pls. consider Cigna TTK protect for your next comparison. I think it is one the better poilicies around at a lesser premium. Thanks.

Do let us know what you think about the article