What is the best date to start a mutual fund SIP? Results from 4000+ 10 Year SIP Returns!

One of the common newbie questions regarding mutual fund SIPs is: What is the best date to start a mutual fund SIP? Nothing wrong with the question, but as in most cases, the answers are often wrong. In this post, I discuss the data of 4147 10-year Sensex SIP retuns computed between Jan 1991 and Sep 2008 to find out if there is a “best date” for starting a SIP.

Anyone who has stared at market graphs long enough will tell you that is not possible to find such patterns in the stock market. That is fine one day that will offer better returns. If this is possible, the entire math associated with the markets will have to be re-written. It is one thing to talk about this and another to show proof. That is what I would like to do in this post.

To be frank, I have better things to do with my time, but as they say there is a sucker born every minute to read the biased analysis of a short-sighted analyst (also born every minute). Therefore it becomes necessary to dig deep and publish results that are not of any personal use.

How to find the best date to start a mutual fund SIP (if there is one)

1: Get Sensex data. I have used data from Jan 1991.

2: Choose a 10-year SIP period (reasonably long enough and something that most investors do not do)

3: Run a 10Y SIP starting on 1st July1991. The return is 10.903% (the reason for excessive decimals should be obvious below). Then shift the 10Y SIP by a day. So the next SIP starts on 2nd July 1991 and so on.

4: So the first 1st SIP date = 1st, 2nd SIP date = 2nd, 3rd SIP date = 3rd and so on. We get 21 SIP dates in July 1991 and the returns are plotted below.

Please look at the difference in returns in the x-axis. Any investor with half a brain will see this graph and recognise that there is no such thing as “best date for SIP” and move on to other things like for example yesterdays post: How to select suitable debt mutual funds with low credit risk? You are more than welcome to read on as an analyst

As an analyst, we should not get satisfied so easily. We need to repeat the above excercise for Aug 1991, Sep 1991, ….. When this is done, we end up 207 months of such data and a total of 4147 10-year SIP returns.

Result: Is there a best date to start a SIP?

The difference between the max SIP return and the minimum SIP return for each of those 207 months is shown below.

best date to start a mutual fund SIP

This enough proof that you get no great advantage in picking and choosing a SIP for better returns. That is simply not possible. The difference is simply too small. Each month has about 18-20 trading days. Aside from the max and min, there will still be about 16-17 other returns possible. Stop searching for the best SIP date!! IT DOES NOT EXIST!

Here is the full table of results.

Month & Year Difference between max and min return Max return SIP date falls after 15th of the month(1 = yes and 0 = No) Min Return SIP date falls before 15th of the month (1 = yes and 0 = No)
7-1991 0.08037% 1 0
8-1991 0.09169% 1 0
9-1991 0.09773% 1 0
10-1991 0.08271% 1 1
11-1991 0.08853% 1 1
12-1991 0.05274% 1 1
1-1992 0.14514% 1 1
2-1992 0.11094% 1 0
3-1992 0.18654% 1 1
4-1992 0.12744% 1 1
5-1992 0.12460% 1 0
6-1992 0.09663% 1 1
7-1992 0.16426% 1 0
8-1992 0.13410% 1 1
9-1992 0.15496% 1 1
10-1992 0.16333% 1 1
11-1992 0.17218% 1 1
12-1992 0.08953% 1 1
1-1993 0.15068% 1 1
2-1993 0.14397% 1 1
3-1993 0.18767% 1 1
4-1993 0.15008% 1 1
5-1993 0.20870% 1 1
6-1993 0.15090% 1 1
7-1993 0.15570% 1 1
8-1993 0.16278% 1 1
9-1993 0.17066% 1 1
10-1993 0.15706% 1 1
11-1993 0.14010% 1 1
12-1993 0.12329% 1 1
1-1994 0.11151% 1 1
2-1994 0.12733% 1 1
3-1994 0.13261% 1 1
4-1994 0.13514% 1 1
5-1994 0.13708% 1 1
6-1994 0.14076% 1 1
7-1994 0.14834% 1 1
8-1994 0.14958% 1 1
9-1994 0.15643% 1 1
10-1994 0.14905% 1 1
11-1994 0.17917% 1 1
12-1994 0.11583% 1 1
1-1995 0.16133% 1 1
2-1995 0.12765% 1 1
3-1995 0.15949% 1 1
4-1995 0.11917% 1 1
5-1995 0.17473% 1 1
6-1995 0.14187% 1 1
7-1995 0.18834% 1 1
8-1995 0.25278% 1 1
9-1995 0.13847% 1 1
10-1995 0.27561% 1 1
11-1995 0.16627% 1 1
12-1995 0.08877% 1 1
1-1996 0.28993% 1 1
2-1996 0.11374% 1 1
3-1996 0.10873% 1 1
4-1996 0.10749% 1 1
5-1996 0.23690% 1 1
6-1996 0.12132% 1 1
7-1996 0.26041% 1 1
8-1996 0.11534% 1 1
9-1996 0.11961% 1 1
10-1996 0.24104% 1 1
11-1996 0.12305% 1 1
12-1996 0.11350% 1 1
1-1997 0.26106% 1 1
2-1997 0.11324% 1 1
3-1997 0.26425% 1 1
4-1997 0.13272% 1 1
5-1997 0.13691% 1 1
6-1997 0.13814% 1 1
7-1997 0.24036% 1 1
8-1997 0.14314% 1 1
9-1997 0.14016% 1 1
10-1997 0.16435% 1 1
11-1997 0.12556% 1 1
12-1997 0.14084% 1 1
1-1998 0.14240% 1 1
2-1998 0.12950% 1 1
3-1998 0.13320% 1 1
4-1998 0.13569% 1 1
5-1998 0.12070% 1 1
6-1998 0.13955% 1 1
7-1998 0.13057% 1 1
8-1998 0.11000% 1 1
9-1998 0.12879% 1 1
10-1998 0.13368% 1 1
11-1998 0.13271% 1 1
12-1998 0.13758% 1 1
1-1999 0.14003% 1 1
2-1999 0.14192% 1 1
3-1999 0.14783% 1 1
4-1999 0.14411% 1 1
5-1999 0.12863% 1 1
6-1999 0.14514% 1 1
7-1999 0.15053% 1 1
8-1999 0.15511% 1 1
9-1999 0.15741% 1 1
10-1999 0.14268% 1 1
11-1999 0.14511% 1 1
12-1999 0.15846% 1 1
1-2000 0.13928% 1 1
2-2000 0.16414% 1 1
3-2000 0.16549% 1 1
4-2000 0.14334% 1 1
5-2000 0.15226% 1 1
6-2000 0.14147% 1 1
7-2000 0.13103% 1 1
8-2000 0.13165% 1 0
9-2000 0.12790% 1 1
10-2000 0.12875% 1 1
11-2000 0.13831% 1 0
12-2000 0.12915% 1 0
1-2001 0.13613% 1 0
2-2001 0.11795% 1 1
3-2001 0.14081% 1 0
4-2001 0.10123% 1 1
5-2001 0.15207% 1 0
6-2001 0.14955% 1 0
7-2001 0.10792% 1 1
8-2001 0.17123% 1 0
9-2001 0.10418% 1 1
10-2001 0.12407% 1 0
11-2001 0.13159% 1 0
12-2001 0.09919% 1 1
1-2002 0.15027% 1 0
2-2002 0.09358% 1 1
3-2002 0.10311% 1 1
4-2002 0.14887% 1 1
5-2002 0.13094% 1 0
6-2002 0.08497% 1 1
7-2002 0.15661% 1 1
8-2002 0.10678% 1 1
9-2002 0.09655% 1 1
10-2002 0.10505% 1 0
11-2002 0.12020% 0 0
12-2002 0.13647% 1 0
1-2003 0.25558% 1 0
2-2003 0.09413% 1 1
3-2003 0.32439% 1 0
4-2003 0.11832% 1 0
5-2003 0.12844% 1 0
6-2003 0.09584% 1 1
7-2003 0.16665% 1 0
8-2003 0.14635% 1 0
9-2003 0.15476% 1 0
10-2003 0.15582% 1 0
11-2003 0.12438% 1 1
12-2003 0.15666% 1 0
1-2004 0.12228% 1 1
2-2004 0.12391% 1 1
3-2004 0.12295% 1 1
4-2004 0.10153% 0 1
5-2004 0.15283% 0 0
6-2004 0.10580% 0 0
7-2004 0.13482% 0 0
8-2004 0.16712% 0 0
9-2004 0.19417% 0 0
10-2004 0.13519% 0 0
11-2004 0.15523% 0 0
12-2004 0.16452% 0 0
1-2005 0.09940% 0 1
2-2005 0.08207% 0 0
3-2005 0.13771% 0 0
4-2005 0.10258% 0 0
5-2005 0.10544% 0 0
6-2005 0.12713% 0 0
7-2005 0.13791% 0 0
8-2005 0.14505% 0 0
9-2005 0.15580% 0 0
10-2005 0.12766% 0 0
11-2005 0.17107% 0 0
12-2005 0.16451% 0 0
1-2006 0.16785% 0 0
2-2006 0.12000% 0 1
3-2006 0.17878% 0 0
4-2006 0.16213% 0 0
5-2006 0.19059% 0 0
6-2006 0.19137% 0 0
7-2006 0.20405% 0 0
8-2006 0.22434% 0 0
9-2006 0.17029% 0 0
10-2006 0.22778% 1 0
11-2006 0.20702% 0 0
12-2006 0.15665% 1 0
1-2007 0.29218% 0 0
2-2007 0.14738% 1 1
3-2007 0.23303% 1 0
4-2007 0.24837% 0 0
5-2007 0.32203% 0 0
6-2007 0.19792% 0 0
7-2007 0.32055% 0 0
8-2007 0.28131% 0 0
9-2007 0.19391% 0 1
10-2007 0.32055% 0 0
11-2007 0.28641% 1 0
12-2007 0.23394% 0 0
1-2008 0.24541% 0 0
2-2008 0.23091% 0 0
3-2008 0.20584% 0 1
4-2008 0.29300% 0 0
5-2008 0.26795% 1 0
6-2008 0.26763% 0 0
7-2008 0.27684% 0 0
8-2008 0.25144% 0 0
9-2008 0.31225% 0 0

There are some interesting insighte regarding WHEN the max SIP return and min SIP return occurs.

The min SIP return occured before the 15th of the month ~ 63% of the 207 months. The max SIP return occured after 15th ~ 76%. HOWEVER, after April 2004, the min occured before 15th and max after 15th only ~ 11% of the 54 months studied.

Conclusion

So don’t go about assuming there is a pattern when there is none! There is no best date for starting a SIP. In fact, as explained here: MF FAQ: part 1 and here: MF FAQ: part 2 there is no need for you to start a SIP and I recommend that you don’t. Just invest as much as possible whenever you get money (each month for many) directly by making a manual transaction at the AMC site.

Do not waste time on such trivial matters. If you want to become rich, you should first think like a rich person and not worry about peanuts.

Want to conduct a sales-free "basics of money management" session in your office?
I conduct free seminars to employees or societies. Only the very basics and getting-started steps are discussed (no scary math):For example: How to define financial goals, how to save tax with a clear goal in mind; How to use a credit card for maximum benefit; When to buy a house; How to start investing; where to invest; how to invest for and after retirement etc. depending on the audience. If you are interested, you can contact me: freefincal [at] Gmail [dot] com. I can do the talk via conferencing software, so there is no cost for your company. If you want me to travel, you need to cover my airfare (I live in Chennai)

Connect with us on social media


Do check out my books


You Can Be Rich Too with Goal-Based InvestingYou can be rich too with goal based investing

My first book is meant to help you ask the right questions, seek the right answers and since it comes with nine online calculators, you can also create customg solutions for your lifestye! Get it now . It is also available in Kindle format .

Gamechanger: Forget Startups, Join Corporate & Still Live the Rich Life You Want

Gamechanger: Forget Start-ups, Join Corporate and Still Live the Rich Life you want
My second book is meant for young earners to get their basics right from day one! It will also help you travel to exotic places at low cost! Get it or gift it to a youngearner

The ultimate guide to travel by Pranav Surya

Travel-Training-Kit-Cover This is a deep dive analysis into vacation planning, finding cheap flights, budget accommodation, what to do when travelling, how travelling slowly is better financially and psychologically with links to the web pages and hand-holding at every step. Get the pdf for ₹199 (instant download)

Create a "from start to finish" financial plan with this free robo advisory software template


Free Apps for your Android Phone

All calculators from our book, “You can be Rich Too" are now available on Google Play!
Install Financial Freedom App! (Google Play Store)
Install Freefincal Retirement Planner App! (Google Play Store)
Find out if you have enough to say "FU" to your employer (Google Play Store)

About Freefincal

Freefincal has open-source, comprehensive Excel spreadsheets, tools, analysis and unbiased, conflict of interest-free commentary on different aspects of personal finance and investing. If you find the content useful, please consider supporting us by (1) sharing our articles and (2) disabling ad-blockers for our site if you are using one. We do not accept sponsored posts, links or guest posts request from content writers and agencies.

Blog Comment Policy

Your thoughts are vital to the health of this blog and are the driving force behind the analysis and calculators that you see here. We welcome criticism and differing opinions. I will do my very best to respond to all comments asap. Please do not include hyperlinks or email ids in the comment body. Such comments will be moderated and I reserve the right to delete the entire comment or remove the links before approving them.

3 thoughts on “What is the best date to start a mutual fund SIP? Results from 4000+ 10 Year SIP Returns!

  1. Dear Pattu Sir,
    Some years back I had done similar analysis based on daily, weekly and monthly sip over a period of 3Y, 5Y and 10Y period. I didn’t find much difference between these sips. Therefore now days I’m investing manually based on fund availability.

  2. I invest in about 7 MFs and I did my own excel analysis for period over last 4 years to find out best period to invest, in beginning of month or in the mid .. It stayed inconclusive… And I am back to 1st of every month… I also try to time it some times.. but that’s rare

  3. Good Analysis.
    Specially for some of the so called advisers who claim to give best advice on the date of SIP. I had such advice from one of the broker who wanted me to open my account with his firm.
    I liked the final sentence and impressed “If you want to become rich, you should first think like a rich person and not worry about peanuts”.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *