"How can I fund my goal if the market crashes a few years before I need the money?" is a question that I have often encountered. In this post (and the next), I address this issue with some specific examples.
An exit strategy is more important than an entry strategy
Suppose I can invest Rs. 1,000 a month and after a few years, the money has grown to Rs. 1,00,000 (more than possible seen it happen with a Rs. 500 SIP). Should I worry about when to invest 1,000 looking at market levels (aka dip buying) or should I be worried about the risk associated with the 1,00,000?
The point is, no matter when you buy, if the market crashes, the corpus will fall in value. Therefore, I would rather focus my time and energy on the managing the risk associated with the corpus while systematically investing each month. Read more: Managing Risk Without Stopping Mutual Fund SIPs.
Multiple solutions to every problem
Every problem has multiple solutions and it is immature to claim one is better than the other. Just a matter of choosing a strategy that we are comfortable with. Reducing corpus risk (aka de-risking) is no different.
For example, I can continue to invest systematically and
- Change the asset allocation of my portfolio (equity:fixed income ratio) as per market conditions (aka dynamic asset allocation)
- Change the asset allocation with a set plan (aka strategic asset allocation)
- Use a combination of (1) and (2) above.
In addition to the above, I must also have a de-risking strategy in mind.
This post is about de-risking strategies. Consider that my asset allocation is 60% equity and 40% fixed income for a financial goal that is 15 years away. To understand how this is chosen in the first place, see deciding on asset allocation for a financial goal.
I cannot afford to maintain this asset allocation for the entire 15 years. As the goal approaches, I must have a strategy in place to reduce equity allocation. This is what the title refers.
Again there are multiple de-risking strategies and I will refer to two that appeal to me.
Returns do not matter
Surprising as it seems, investment returns do not say much about our ability to finance the future. A guy with an LIC policy can end up with more money than an equity guy. Not just because of the risk associated with the latter, but because of the amount invested.
When I perform a financial audit, the only question matters to me is, "what is the corpus worth?".
If it is retirement, I ask :"If I retire with it today, how long can I be financially independent".
Or to be more specific, "Is my fixed income asset allocation enough to guarantee me an inflation-protected income for the first 10-15 years in retirement" and the equity allocation enough to grow undisturbed for that amount of time to serve me later.
If it is my son's education, I ask "What kind of education can I afford today?".
My son is only about 7 years old and in the 1st standard. By the time he goes to 8th or 9th standard I will have a better idea of how much I will need to pay for his education. So I then starting ensuring that my fixed income assets have an amount close to that. So in the next 3-4 years, before he goes to college, the corpus is reasonably protected from market volatility.
The idea behind this strategy is to shift from equity to fixed income assets such that you ensure things go to plan. I like this because there is nothing technical about this. Just simple common sense.
This idea might seem impossible to you if you have just started out. Trust me, I would have felt the same 3-4 years ago. Give it a little time and you will see what I mean. December is personal financial audit month. So I will give more concrete examples.
Changing Asset Allocation in Stages
The second method is to change asset allocation with time. Or in particular decrease equity allocation gradually. An illustration is shown below. I will post back-testing results with S&P 500 based on this strategy tomorrow.
Other de-risking strategies based on market timing, fear of impending events, Lok Sabha elections etc. can easily be formulated.
Check out reviews for You can be rich too
If you have not purchased it, you can do via Amazon.in. Please consider writing a review either at Amazon.in
The second part of this study is here: How to systematically reduce the risk associated with a SIP
Register for the New Delhi DIY Investor meet: April 23rd 2017Get free, yet comprehensive calculators, tools and analysis delivered to your mailbox! Subscribe to get posts via email
Buy our New Book!You Can Be Rich With Goal-based Investing A book by P V Subramanyam (subramoney.com) & M Pattabiraman. Read more about the book and pre-order now!