ETFs vs Index Funds: Stop assuming lower expenses equals higher returns!

So many people make the mistake of assuming that just because an ETF has a lower expense ratio than an index fund, it will result in higher returns (excluding demat account fee and brokerage), There is no evidence to this. The return from an index fund or an ETF depends on several factors. In this post, we will see how an index fund with a significantly higher return than an ETF can result in comparable or even a bit more return.

In the case of an index fund, how closely it tracks the index is measured by the tracking error. Although this is not an intuitive number, too many people use it forgetting that sometimes index funds can outperform their indices for the wrong reasons! So it is important to always use returns to track performance.

ETFs vs Index Funds: Stop assuming lower expenses equals higher return

In this case of an ETF, the return that one gets is decided by the price of the unit and not the NAV of the unit. If you are new to ETFs and how they work, please start with this post: How ETFs are different from Mutual Funds: A Beginner’s Guide and then Interested in ETFs? Here is how you can select ETFs by checking how easy it is to buy/sell them,

Only when the difference between the ETF price and ETF NAV is not too much, see for example how to check this here: What is the best way to invest in Nifty Next 50 Index – can one use the NAV as a proxy for the price. Unfortunately, all portals use ETF NAV for computing tracking error and returns. The ETF tracking error is not representative of how much investor returns differ from index returns.  For this article, I use some graphs previously used to compare a NIfty Next 50 ETF and an index fund.

ICICI Prudential Nifty Next 50 Index Fund-Direct Plan vs  Reliance ETF Junior BeES

Earlier I was under the impression that the NAV reported does not include ETF dividends (they declare these and it can either be put back into the fund or distributed). However, thankfully, this is not the case, The dividends (if any) seem to treated as reinvested for NAV computation.

Three years: Index fund NAV vs ETF NAV

First, let us compare the 3 year rolling return and rolling risk of ETF and index fund. We shall use the ETF NAV.

Three years: Index fund NAV vs ETF Price

When we use the ETF price instead of the NAV (the right thing to do), the outperformance is not as high.

The risk (shown in the bottom panel) is also higher for the ETF price due to market forces. However, notice that even though the ETF has significantly lower expense ratio than the index fund (about 0.5% at the time of writing), this does not result in return or risk outperformance.

The trend is the same for four and five years. Check out the video below or this post: What is the best way to invest in Nifty Next 50 Index?

SBI Sensex ETF vs Tata Index fund 3 year rolling returns

SBI Sensex ETF vs Tata Index fund rolling returnsSBI Nifty Index fund Vs ICICI Nifty ETF rolling returns

SBI Nifty Index fund Vs ICICI Nifty ETF rolling returns

For both of the above cases, notice that sometimes the ETF does better (NAV was here) and sometimes the index fund. So outperformance does not depend on expense alone. So please stop assuming lower expenses will result in higher returns!

Video Version

ETFs vs Index fund: Stop assuming lower expenses is better!

Summary: What should be done?

I would suggest the following:

  1. Stay away from ETFs where the price to nav difference is frequently high. See List of Index Mutual Funds and ETFs in India: What to choose and what to avoid
  2. Always compare returns of the index fund with the index fund and the same with the ETF. Do not use a tracking error.
  3. Do not forget to factor in brokerage and demat fee when you are comparing index funds with ETFs.
  4. There is only one situation where lower expense will result in higher returns. That is with direct funds as the portfolio is identical to that of the regular fund: Which are the most popular direct plan mutual funds?

Latest from freefincal on YouTube

How to manage money with your spouse? Together, Separately!!

Avoid Real Estate Investment Trusts (REIT’s) : Here is why!

 

Do share if you found this useful

Create a "from start to finish" financial plan with this unique open-source robo advisory software template


 Don't like ads but want to support the site? Subscribe to the ad-free newsletter! 
You will get the full post-ad-free delivered to your inbox for Rs. 3000 a year. Follow this link to read the terms and sign up! 


About the Author M Pattabiraman author of freefincal.comM. Pattabiraman is the co-author of two books: You can be rich too with goal based investing and Gamechanger. “Pattu” as he is popularly known, publishes unbiased, promotion-free research, analysis and holistic money management advice. Freefincal serves more than one million readers a year with numbers based analysis on topical issues and has more than a 100 free calculators on different aspects of insurance and investment analysis, including a robo advisory template for use by beginners. Contact information: freefincal {at} Gmail {dot} com He conducts free money management sessions for corporates (see details below). Previous engagements include World Bank, RBI, BHEL, Asian Paints.

Content Policy

Freefincal has original unbiased, conflict-of-interest-free,  topical reports, reviews, commentary and analysis on all aspects of personal finance like mutual funds, stocks, insurance etc. All guest authors and contributors to the site also do not have any conflict of interest. If you find the content useful, please consider supporting us by (1) sharing our articles and (2) disabling ad-blockers for our site if you are using one. No promotional content We do not accept sponsored posts and link exchange requests from content writers and agencies. This is our privacy policy Our website is non-profit in nature. The revenue from the advertisement will only be used for hosting charges, domain registration charges, specific plugins necessary for traffic growth and analytics services for search engine optimisation.
Want to conduct a sales-free "basics of money management" session in your office?
I conduct free seminars to employees or societies. Only the very basics and getting-started steps are discussed (no scary math):For example: How to define financial goals, how to save tax with a clear goal in mind; How to use a credit card for maximum benefit; When to buy a house; How to start investing; where to invest; how to invest for and after retirement etc. depending on the audience. If you are interested, you can contact me: freefincal [at] Gmail [dot] com. I can do the talk via conferencing software, so there is no cost for your company. If you want me to travel, you need to cover my airfare (I live in Chennai)

Connect with us on social media


Do check out my books


You Can Be Rich Too with Goal-Based Investing

You can be rich too with goal based investingMy first book is meant to help you ask the right questions, seek the right answers and since it comes with nine online calculators, you can also create custom solutions for your lifestyle! Get it now.  It is also available in Kindle format.
Gamechanger: Forget Startups, Join Corporate & Still Live the Rich Life You WantGamechanger: Forget Start-ups, Join Corporate and Still Live the Rich Life you wantMy second book is meant for young earners to get their basics right from day one! It will also help you travel to exotic places at low cost! Get it or gift it to a young earner

The ultimate guide to travel by Pranav Surya

Travel-Training-Kit-Cover This is a deep dive analysis into vacation planning, finding cheap flights, budget accommodation, what to do when travelling, how travelling slowly is better financially and psychologically with links to the web pages and hand-holding at every step.  Get the pdf for ₹199 (instant download)

Free Apps for your Android Phone

All calculators from our book, “You can be Rich Too” are now available on Google Play!
Install Financial Freedom App! (Google Play Store)
Install Freefincal Retirement Planner App! (Google Play Store)
Find out if you have enough to say "FU" to your employer (Google Play Store)

Blog Comment Policy

Your thoughts are vital to the health of this blog and are the driving force behind the analysis and calculators that you see here. We welcome criticism and differing opinions. I will do my very best to respond to all comments asap. Please do not include hyperlinks or email ids in the comment body. Such comments will be moderated and I reserve the right to delete the entire comment or remove the links before approving them.
Updated: March 22, 2019 — 10:10 am

1 Comment

Add a Comment
  1. Now this is insightful!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *