A Mutual Fund SIP is Hope, Not a Strategy!

Too many investors believe that keeping their SIP alive and running over the 'long-term' is all that is needed to get 'good returns' from equity and achieve all their financial goals. Now that might happen in a fairy tale, but not in real life.

In real life, the SIP is a  method of buying mutual fund units periodically and not a strategy. In real life the SIP over the 'long-term'  - which varies from 3Y to 5Y to 10Y to more, fails much too often.

Want proof?  Here is exhibit 1A.

Dollar Cost Averaging aka SIP analysis of S&P 500 and BSE Sensex

Whether you compare SIP returns with recurring deposit returns over 2Y, 5Y or 10Y, there will always be some funds which have beat an RD and some which have not.

Exhibit 1B: Value Research SIP Returns page

  • Out of the 594 equity funds which are at least 3Y old, 143 have returns that are less than 10%. Difference bet max and min  return = 39.5%
  • Out of the 288 equity funds which are at least 5Y old, 46 have returns that are less than 10%. Difference bet max and min  return = 32.4%
  • Out of the 166 equity funds which are at least 10Y old, 41 have returns that are less than 10%. Difference bet max and min  return = 21.3%
  • Out of the 64 equity funds which are at least 15Y old, no funds have returns that are less than 10%. Difference bet max and min  return = 13.2%
  • Out of the 10 equity funds which are at least 20Y old, no have returns that are less than 10%.Difference bet max and min  return = 13.8%

No, the moral of the story is not long-term = 15Y and above!!

The moral of the story is that there are only 10 funds which are 20Y old and the last 20Y was fantastic for equity.

The moral of the story is that the next 20Y may not be like the last 20. After 20 years, we will have 500+ funds which will be 20Y old! Do you expect all of them to have beat a recurring deposit or get a double digit return?!

The amusing part is that many interpret these facts (esp. the difference bet max and min return) as 'fund selection is important, therefore you need an advisor blah blah'.

To say the very least, this is immature. Mutual fund selection is NOT important. In fact, it is the least important part of the portfolio management process.

Why? Because the right mutual fund cannot be selected!!

A portfolio with volatile assets should be monitored with the right personal benchmarks. To assume that a SIP will do well in the end (or it is not the end! - Guess the movie) is mere hope. And hope is not a strategy.

The best performer today could become a dud in a few years. So even if you choose the best funds today, it is imperative that the portfolio be reviewed and necessary course corrections taken. Knowing how to review is more important than knowing how to choose!

Yes, there is a lot of room left for a country like India to grow, and one must do all we can to benefit from this opportunity. When the GDP grows, our equity portfolios should at least grow at the same rate. This rate has to be above inflation since it is the rate at which businesses borrow.

BUT, that is the story of the asset class. Asset class returns NEED NOT match investor returns even if there are no behavioural flaws (gap) like selling low, staying away, doing nothing etc.

In fact, investor returns SHOULD NOT match asset class returns! (think 2008) Investor returns should match investor requirements - nothing less, nothing more (imo of course).

Not investor dreams or expectations (for they may not be logical), but investor requirements. Requirements that are derived from of a goal-planing exercise like this one: A Step-By-Step Guide to Long Term Goal-Based Investing.

If you started an SIP with hope, you've been had. Would the guys who go, "in the long run equity will outperform all asset classes", fund your goals if they turn out wrong?!

No, I am not asking you to stop your SIPs or that equity will not work. I am saying it may not work!

R. Balakrishnan put it beautifully: "Equity will give returns but not when you want it to!" That just about sums it up.

Ignore the enthusiastic SIP selling (esp the memes) and the over-confidence. Understand your requirements better and do not hesitate to make changes to your portfolio accordingly. The way I see it, this is a personal process. I will try and provide some examples.

Whether you automate systematic investing or not, active portfolio management is essential in equity.

Active management does not mean timing the market!  I had covered this in Simple Steps to De-risk Your Investment Portfolio. There are so many ways to do this. We will have to develop our own system.

Moral of the story: Irrespective of whether a portfolio is actively managed or not, equity investing comes with no guarantees. Better to realise it now before it becomes too late for our financial goals.

Install Financial Freedom App! (Google Play Store)

Install Freefincal Retirement Planner App! (Google Play Store)

book-footer

Buy our New Book!

You Can Be Rich With Goal-based Investing A book by  P V Subramanyam (subramoney.com) & M Pattabiraman. Hard bound. Price: Rs. 399/- and Kindle Rs. 349/-. Read more about the book and pre-order now!
Practical advice + calculators for you to develop personalised investment solutions

Thank you for reading. You may also like

About Freefincal

Freefincal has open-source, comprehensive Excel spreadsheets, tools, analysis and unbiased, conflict of interest-free commentary on different aspects of personal finance and investing. If you find the content useful, please consider supporting us by (1) sharing our articles and (2) disabling ad-blockers for our site if you are using one. We do not accept sponsored posts, links or guest posts request from content writers and agencies.

Blog Comment Policy

Your thoughts are vital to the health of this blog and are the driving force behind the analysis and calculators that you see here. We welcome criticism and differing opinions. I will do my very best to respond to all comments asap. Please do not include hyperlinks or email ids in the comment body. Such comments will be moderated and I reserve the right to delete  the entire comment or remove the links before approving them.

23 thoughts on “A Mutual Fund SIP is Hope, Not a Strategy!

  1. Sandeep

    Pattu Sir, Agree with you, However to Small investors currently it is only one option which may give inflation beating returns. Agree to your point that investors should actively manage and do the asset allocation.

    Reply
    1. freefincal

      I am not against SIP. Small investors must learn portfolio management if they are going to DIY. Is that not possible?

      Reply
    1. freefincal

      Where is the Ummeed directed at matters. Is it just on the asset class or our preparation to manage risk in the folio.

      Reply
  2. Shrinath Savoor

    So, you have now confused us even more. Please answer the foloowing questions:
    1. Should one go in for SIP's
    2. If I have a lump sum (say Rs 5 lacs) to invest, should I invest the whole amount in one go or should I put it in a liquid fund and do a STP into an equity fund.
    best regards
    Shri

    Reply
    1. freefincal

      1. Should one go in for SIP's
      "No, I am not asking you to stop your SIPs or that equity will not work. I am saying it may not work!"

      2. If I have a lump sum (say Rs 5 lacs) to invest, should I invest the whole amount in one go or should I put it in a liquid fund and do a STP into an equity fund.
      How to invest a lump sum in an equity mutual fund?

      Reply
    1. freefincal

      No it is modified from "Everything will be all right in the end. If it's not all right, it is not yet the end” from The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel

      Reply
  3. Deepak

    I must appreciate the author for writing such blog when the majority of MFs industry including IFAs, Financial Planner and portfolio managers are suggesting to start SIP in long term equity MF to build the wealth. Investors mind sets have started believing this as a strategy.

    The author is right by saying if you invest in equity through SIPs or Lump sum the risk is not eliminated. There is no guarantee that the investment in equity MF will fetch you desired profits in 3y, 5y, 10y, 15y or more.

    Whether you are investing through advisors or directly, it is very much necessary to monitor the fund performance.

    One can build a strategy to monitor the fund performance every six months or yearly and take informed and realistic decision whether to continue with the fund, redeem or switch.

    After all it is your own hard earned money and you would never wish to lose it.

    Regards,

    Reply
  4. Balaji Narayanan

    Excellent article/ blog post. The author is using facts (to create enough fear) to dispel myth about SIPs that they will somehow de-risk everything that is associated with equity investing. Actively managing risk is paramount even in SIP is an eye opener.

    Reply
      1. ltinvestment

        Kindly refer your last line of below paragraph.

        Quote
        Ignore the enthusiastic SIP selling (esp the memes) and the over-confidence. Understand your requirements better and do not hesitate to make changes to your portfolio accordingly. The way I see it, this is a personal process. I will try and provide some examples.
        Unquote

        Reply

Do let us know what you think about the article