Each week I try and answer generic questions from readers. Here is this weeks edition. If you have a question, you can use the form below and I will address it next week (if I can).
Abhi: Hello Mr. Pattabhiraman, Trust you are doing good! In the first chapter of your book “You can be rich too” (Chapter: “Where are you today”) you introduce the concepts of one’s Networth, income statement, cash flow statement & goal sheet. Your workbook for the chapter also asks the reader to prepare them. I found the Networth calculator (this is part of the nine calculator modules that come with the book). However, there seem to be no templates for income statement or cash flow statement. Even the help section of the site doesn’t talk about these two statements. Are they not necessary? If they are required for later stages of financial planning, can you please share the link to such tools that you may have developed? Look forward to hearing from you Abhi
Pattu: Good question! The networth calculation serves only one purpose. It tells you where you stand today. Beyond a point it is not very useful. I strongly believe that once I account for
- my unpredictable future needs via life, health, accident insurance and a healthy emergency fund
- my predictable future needs by investing in a suitable asset allocation and as much as possible, as early as possible, everything else will fall in place.
This is the reason I did not feel any need for those sheets beyond the hand-written worksheet templates. You can read more about this here: How tracking investments instead of expenses changed my life!
Rakesh: Hi Pattu, Had a query on Real estate. Suppose a person bought an apartment for 60 lakhs in 2009 and sold it for 1.2 cr in 2017. What will be the tax implication? What if he invests all the amount in MF – liquid, debt and equity, does he still need to pay any tax? Appreciate your reply. Thanks, Rakesh
Pattu: In this case, there is no change in the tax implication due to the shift of CII base year from 1980 to 2001. The long-term capital gains computed after indexation will be taxed at a flat rate of 20% + cess.
The gains (up to 50 Lakh) can be set of by investing in Section 54EC designated bonds for 3Y. At current rates, the post-tax return will be more or less equal to an SB account for those in 30% slab.
If the investment is not made in this bond or if a new property is not constructed with the gains, tax as mentioned above has to be paid.
An illustration is here: Long Term Capital Gains Computation with base year 2001
Ps: I am not answering your other question. Please consult a SEBI registered fee-only financial planner from this list
Sandeep: Pattu Sir, Help out with views on employer provided superannuation fund. While listing all assets, how accumulated value is accounted as my asset side? In terms of liquid or semi-liquid asset or shall I exclude it from total asset value calculation?
Pattu: It is part of your fixed income or debt asset allocation. Liquid or semi-liquid does not matter.
Avinash: Sir, Have you done any article on how mutual funds work. Most of your articles are on how to analyze MF performance. Is a there a general guide on how MF works. How people contribute the money.What happens to the money contributed. Do MF managers buy stocks every month with the money that is contributed. How much commission do they take home. Who regulates MF market. Is this same as stock market regulator. What happens to the fund when people withdraw. Who are MF managers. How they get selected. How much control do consumers have on MFs. What happens to the dividends given on the stocks held by the MFs. Who are these CAMS etc.Can Mf redemption linked to the bank account. Is the redemption instantaneous. How one can get started.(Direct MFs you have covered to an extent i guess) A example plan to get started in say a SIP plan.Then how to analyse the performance(This I think these are your current articles). Are these covered in your latest book.
Pattu: There is no fun in writing about stuff that is well covered by other authors (unless I need to sell mutual funds). I try and cover lesser known aspects of mutual funds from time to time. Some of the answers to your questions can be found here:
How much control do consumers have on MFs? I don’t know what you mean by control. The only way you can question performance (if that is what you mean) is by exiting the fund! For other problems, you can uses SEBI online complaint system.
Investing in a fund is the very last step. The book covers how to define a goal, choose a suitable asset allocation, pick a fund based on quantitative and qualitative parameters and analyse performance.
I will try and covers the basics of a mutual fund later.
Krishnapratap: Hi Pattu Sir, 1. What is the guarantee that MF that will always give positive returns and that to beat inflation in long term say 10 years or above? 2. What kind of returns one can expect from Liquid Funds, Balanced Funds, Small Cap, Large Cap, Mid Cap and Equity Funds? My question is how much minimum returns one can expect for a period of 10 years or above for all categories of MF?
Pattu: You may have heard the standard mutual fund disclaimer, past performance is not indicative of future performance. This actually means,
past returns are not indicative of future returns, because past risk is the minium guarantee when it comes to future risk.
There is absolutely no guarantee that an instrument linked to market value on day to day basis will produce any guaranteed except risk. The only way around this problem is:
manage risk effectively: Simple Steps to De-risk Your Investment Portfolio
Expect risk and returns, not just returns = keep expectations lower
Under-promise to over-deliver.
I and Ashal expect only 10% from equity 10+Y from now. This keeps us calmer, with no itch to churn the portfolio. And once you realise that returns do not matter, you become a zen-like investor. (meditative – looking inward and not outward = noise).
Here are graphs that I will never show if I had to make a living selling mutual funds.
5-year rolling SIP returns
10-year rolling SIP returns
15-year rolling SIP returns
Notice the number of times the return has fallen below 10% (before taxes).
If you want guarantees that your SIP investments will ‘work’ or help you achieve your goals, you are barking up the wrong tree.
These are taken from: Dollar Cost Averaging aka SIP analysis of S&P 500 and BSE Sensex
If you (anyone reading this) marry into a SIP thinking that is all you need to do because India is a “growth story”, the jokes on you.
In response this yapping, I always get asked:
What would you choose between certain death and a shot at being alive?
Equity investing is like fire. You can’t afford to do without it, but get over confident it will scar you for life.
Mutual Fund Equity investing changed my life. In 8Y I went from a net worth of – 3 lakhs (debt) to financially independent. With disciplined investing and disciplined portfolio management, anyone can do it.
Expect minimum risk first, then minium returns will become clearer.
Here are some conservative estimates over 10Y
Liquid Funds 5-6%
Balanced Funds 10%
Small Cap 10%
Large Cap 10%
Mid Cap 10%
The most dangerous behaviour that I have observed is, many investors cannot invest a lot of money. So they want to make up for that by expecting more and taking more risk in the hope that it would lead to more returns. Hope is not a strategy.
Jay: Can MNC funds (2 of them) be considered as diversified MFs? They do seem to have better diversification than the NIFTY MNC index although there is a theme associated with them. Can they be considered for long term investment?
Pattu: Why two? Are you referring to the Birla and Util funds? Amusingly both have severely underperformed wrt Nifty MNC (price) index. When the stock universe narrows, so should the time over which we judge the fund?
In any case, there should be considerable overlap between the two MNC funds. You certainly can consider one of these for long term investment, as long as they are no the only funds in the equity basket.
Padma: Sir, I have gone through a few online MF Portfolio management tools with auto upload of transaction history via a consolidated transaction statement across all registrars generated through CAMS. Very few offer to auto upload CAMS statement and analyse portfolio data and VRO Portfolio tools provides a lifetime XIRR of all my transactions uploaded as per CAMS statement . What I am interested to know is XIRR between any two dates of choice in respect of the set of transactions made by me , which would be useful to know how my portfolio performed during select phases of markets. I tried doing this by generating & uploading statements as per dates of my choice within which I wish to analyse performance. The process of upload takes only paired transactions of buy & sell made between the selected dates and prompts to delete purchase transactions made before the start date of statement / analysis, as corresponding sell transaction is not appearing within the statement duration. Ideally the algorithm should take NAVs between start & end dates of the uploaded statement and use those returns for XIRR computation, in respect of those purchase / switch-in transactions which were made before the start date. Can I do this analysis with auto upload on your blog. If not can you please suggest what are the online resources both free or paid models where such XIRR analysis can be done. All the better if such resources throw some light on other qualitative parameters of portfolio and provide sectoral orientation of our portfolios at periodic time frames e.g., each quarter/ half year/ yearly within the selected dates for analysis. Thanks a lot and appreciate your valuable service. if you can provide such portfolio management tools with great analytical, presentation & excel export features, whether free or on paid model, it will be highly appreciated by serious MF investors and also highly patronised. Thanks once again Sir.
Pattu: I don’t know a way in which the consolidated statement can be auto-exported to Excel, but I am building a tool in which similar analysis can be done. Watch this space 🙂
Ranjan: Is it advisable to rebalance a portfolio comprising 100% “Balanced” funds which by definition have to maintain an Equity:debt ratio of approx 60:40 by themselves ?
Pattu: Not 60:40, balanced funds must have min 65% equity over a year and they typically hold more. I would recommend treating them as pure equity funds and rebalance with debt from elsewhere.
Dilip: Can you please suggest a tool/excel, which allow us to maintain Personal Portfolio Finance of all LIC/Expenses/Bank/Equity/MF (SIP/lumpsum) ? Also where can I find what portfolio scripts are there within my Total Portfolio of MF?
Pattu: You can do this online at Perfios. I got a tracker for mutual funds and another for PPF. It is easy to integrate these two. I don’t believe in tracking expenses, but you can also integrate any free expense tracker in Excel with these. Alternatively, there is a google sheet for stocks + mutual funds.
Gaurav Mehta: Dear Sir, I have read your views on NPS and understand that you are not much in favour of voluntary NPS. However, I wanted your opinion on my specific situation. I am in 30% tax bracket and have health, term insurance, & emergency fund in place. I can invest the ~15K (saved in taxes from voluntary NPS investment of 50K) in equity funds. Does it make sense to do so? What I like about NPS is its balanced equity fund like nature (by opting for 50-75% equity option) and additional tax break outside 80C/D. Also, as per current rules, only about 20% of the corpus will be taxable at the time of withdrawal, which can also be staggered to reduce tax liability.
Pattu: You are mistaken in your understanding of NPS taxation. You will have to buy an annuity for min 40% and the pension from that will be taxable. That is a big waste of money. Out of the rest 60%, 40% can be withdrawn tax-free and 20% is taxable as per slab. Please do not assume your tax slab in retirement will be lower!
The tax break outside 80C is provided for the benefit of the PFRDA to sell NPS. Rest is up to you.
Shrikant: Hello pattu, pl comment upon- is there any change in the taxation on dividend recd from MF in the hands of individual upto Rs. 10.00 lakhs? Recent change of 10% tax dividend tax is applicable to whom? pl clarify. thanks shrikant
Pattu: It does not apply to MF investors. Only stock investors.
Rakesh Dadhania: Dear Pattu sir, thank you for doing wonderful job. in overall financial planning, I am trying to follow the principle of equity:debt ratio, shall I PF and PPF amount as a part of DEBT component? thank you.
Pattu: Yes you should. Thank you.
Abhyankar: want to calculate the shortfall for all goals based on present corpus accumulated? Based on the past returns is there any method to calculate if the goals can be met or not?
Pattu: This is not easy to do as equity returns can be poor for years together. I would suggest taking stock every year with the goal calculator and revised inputs (course in hand), but more serious questions about whether the goal can be met or not can be considered only after a few years.
Shailesh: The mutual fund statement do not give XIRR/CAGR in the form. The tools developed can give the result and i tried it but it is time-consuming for me to enter different transactions (redeem/STP/SIP) in different folios. Is there any other way to “upload” transactions in your tool? Is there any other method to calculate XIRR?
Pattu: How I wish this is possible! I hope someone reading this can help.
Ask Questions with this form
And I will respond to them next week. I welcome tough questions. Please do not ask for investment advice. Before asking, please search the site if the issue has already been discussed. Thank you.
[contact-form][contact-field label=’Name’ type=’name’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Email’ type=’email’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Comment’ type=’textarea’ required=’1’/][/contact-form]
Pune Investor Workshop Feb 26th, 2017
The second Pune workshop will be held on Feb 26th, 2017. You can register for this via this link
You Can Be Rich Too With Goal-Based Investing
Gift it to your Friends and Relatives whom you care more. Already follower of Pattu and Subra’s forum. Ordered 4 more copies to give gift to my friends and eagerly waiting to read
The best book ever on Financial Freedom Planning. Go get it now!
Your first investment should be buying this book
The (nine online) calculators are really awesome and will give you all possible insights
Thank you, readers, for your generous support and patronage.
Amazon Hardcover Rs. 341 15% OFF
Kindle at Amazon.in (Rs. 244.30)
Infibeam Now just Rs. 307 use love10 to get additional 10% OFF.
If you use a mobikwik wallet, and purchase via infibeam, you can get up to 100% cashback!!
- Ask the right questions about money
- get simple solutions
- Define your goals clearly with worksheets
- Calculate the correct asset allocation for each goal.
- Find out how much insurance cover you need, and how much you need to invest with nine online calculator modules
- Learn to choose mutual funds qualitatively and quantitatively.
More information is available here: A Beginner’s Guide To Make Your Money Dreams Come True!
What Readers Say
Also Available At
Amazon.com ($ 3.70 or Rs. 267)
Google Play Store (Rs. 244.30)