Ten Years of Mutual Fund Investing: My Journey and lessons learned

On 19th June 2008, I started investing in mutual funds. These ten years have changed the way I look at risk and even day to day money management. This is my story and lessons I have learned. The broad trajectory should be well known to regular/old readers. This is an account of how I went from spendthrift to debt-bearer to financial independence: The Financial Arrow of Time and My journey: driven by the fear of making the same mistakes again

I had already shared my lessons from mutual fund investing – this was specific to mutual funds. In this post, I discuss other aspects of portfolio management and outlook on money growth. First of all, let me make it clear that ten years is not a big deal. I know many investors who have been investing in the markets and/funds for much, much longer. Since we suffer from solved example syndrome, the stories of such investors will sell well, but they are too private to discuss their journey.

This is only a personal milestone. There is so much to learn. Be it the stock market or life, the moment you sound like you have some experience, you will get kicked to the ground. The simple truth is that out of a million ways to go from point A to point B in ten years, life selected one for me. This does not mean, this is the only way to success (or failure).

How it all began

It was late 2007. My father had passed after an 18 month bed-ridden battle against multiple myeloma. We were all emotionally exhausted. Two months after he passed, my mother was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease – there is nothing fair or unfair about life, it is just pot luck.

Finally, I had some time to take stock of my life. Since I had a hospital expense debt of about 3 lakh (thankfully interest-free as it was from my brother-in-law), I swore that I should never put my family in such a money-situation again.

I started reading news articles and this idea of beating inflation with equity caught my eye. So I asked my health insurance agent about investing in mutual funds. Like many, my first mutual fund was an ELSS fund (in hindsight, this is an unnecessary mistake, but that is life).

So my first fund was Sundaram Tax Saver Dividend Option. I had no idea what that meant and how it was different from growth. This fund and this option were selected by him and since my investment was small, I did not mind. So I started with a SIP of Rs. 1500.

When I started the stocks markets all over the world were in chaos thanks to the Lehmann crisis – but I had no idea (thankfully). About a year or so later, I called my agent again and wanted to start another SIP. He said he will send someone home – but no one came. Why?

From Aug 1st 2009, SEBI had banned entry load in mutual funds. This meant that sales guys would only get commissions from the investment value and not investment amount. Perhaps because of the climate then (post-crash), perhaps because of innumeracy I was told many distributors quit over this ban. They perhaps did not realize that commission taken out of the investment value will grow at the same rate as the investment.

Whatever the reason, this forced me to DIY. If no one would come home to set up a SIP for me, I decided to go “directly” to the AMC. Perhaps it is a generation thing – I did not look for the next easy option – “invest via the bank”.

So I became a direct investor almost 3 years before the introduction of direct plans. So for 3 years, amcs were gobbling up the commission money as there was no distributor. If I wanted a Sundaram Fund, I went to their office. If I wanted a HDFC fund, I went to their office. I had no idea who or what CAMS was.

Around this time, AMCs started opening up proper investing portals. It was possible to buy and sell units online. Then on Jan 1st 2013, the no of funds that I held doubled. All my funds had a regular plan and a direct plan. The new SIPs were automatically routed direct.

By this time, I had stopped my SIP gradually as the amount I was trying to invest each month became higher and higher and I could not lock that much into a SIP as it may affect expenses. So I began buying units manually each month. The first time I did that, I realised a SIP = monthly lump sum. This was about 5-6 years ago.

Initially, I used to invest manually at the start of the month. Then to train myself with the volatility, I used to wait for a “dip” within a month and invest then (the stupid things we do!). Then I did not care. I just invested when I could. Sometimes they were more than a month apart if expenses became high. I religiously started to track investments from 2010 or so in this excel sheet: Using Excel to track investments. I still use it.

By this time I was also making calculators for retirement and other needs (these seeds of freefincal were sown in late 2010ish). I made a financial plan template projecting future needs. This latter became this popular template: Create your own financial plan with this financial planning template and then this: Download the Freefincal Robo Advisory Software Template

Once I realised the power of tracking investing after setting clear goals, I stopped tracking expenses: How tracking investments instead of expenses changed my life! From that point on, it was all about reviewing portfolio growth (not individual funds) based on goals and periodic rebalancing.

My portfolio

So this is the normalized growth of my portfolio and investment in NIfty Next 50 (same dates and same amounts, excluding dividends).

The y-axis values have no meaning (to you). Please don’t start thinking “If I had invested in NN50 ten years ago”. See this analysis: This is my portfolio vs Sensex, Nifty Next 50

This the gain or loss in both portfolios.

Notice for the first 5 years and three months, the returns were zero. The reason you see the gains suddenly shoot up was due to this:

The gain or loss is again plotted (green). The yellow dots represent the annual increase in investment amount. Or What I refer to as the investing CAGR (not investment CAGR). Notice the huge year on year increase in the amount invested in equity mfs in 2010, 2011, 2012. When you dump in money when the market moves sideways, you reap the gains when the tide turns – in my case around the time when economic conditions were favourable and NaMo was announced as the PM candidate  -sheer coincidence.

Please note the above does not mean I invested more in 2010,11,12 than now. That is not possible as I am salaried. What you see above is merely big jumps in equity investment. This was possible because I already had some NPS and PPF investments. So equity had some catching up to do in order to get to 60% in the portfolio. Today my investing CAGR has stabilised (it has too!)

I am pointing this out to show I am an unintelligent brute force investor who was lucky enough to invest more

Do you wish to view your portfolio growth like this? Then download: Mutual Fund Portfolio Growth Visualizer With Index Benchmarking (revised and updated June 2018)

My lessons

If I can call myself successful, then it is only because of one aspect: I did not monitor my portfolio every day. I did not seek information every day and worry about it. I let my money grow peacefully with occasional gardening. My portfolio growth has nothing to do with my ability to choose “good funds” or my education or training. By nature, I am disciplined and hate information.

If I had to list my lessons (no one is asking!), they would be:

1: Get a life! Identify your goal, invest in them and leave them be until it is time for your annual review.

2: Get rid of Financial contacts or groups on WhatsApp, Twitter and Facebook.  An investor is defined by her ability to process information – and the best way to do that is to avoid information. Just like the best way to manage time is to avoid work (or learning to say ‘no’).

3: Invest like your rear end is on fire or life will light it up for you later.

4: If your needs are far away and you see a sideways market, pump in money. That is the best time to invest. Of course, not many can do this.

5: Never forget that these gains are notional. A single event can decrease your holdings by half. Mountaineers believe that they can climb a peak “if the mountain lets them”. Markets are not different. Remember notional losses are real losses. Only notional gains are notional.

6: Your attitude towards money itself and towards profit and loss depends on how much money you have. I have seen my portfolio gain or lose 10s of Rs, 100s –> 1000s —> ….. And along the way I realised that to be successful we need to not only learn to lose/gains lakhs every day but not also yearn for it.

7: Money is a drug. The more you have, the more you want to have. So at some stage, you will have to draw the line. Increasing the amount you give away to help others at the same rate at which your portfolio grows will keep us grounded.

8: To be rich, we must first think like a rich person. Have 10Y, 25Y or  35Y year view of your life. Want To Get Rich? Write Yourself A One Crore Cheque!

9: We cannot buy stuff with returns. Having enough money is more important than getting high returns and no, they are not the same.

10: Concentrate on the portfolio return the most. Individual funds will have up and down ride. As long the portfolio is moving along at a healthy pace, it is fine. This is the main reason for developing the freefincal mutual fund and financial goal tracker This is the only sheet I use to track my goals and investments. When I see kids today talk about “having all investments in the same place for consolidation”, I can only chuckle. This consolidation business is hugely overrated. Investing directly with a few AMCs and using Excel or Google spreadsheet (try this one) or online free tracking portals is more than enough.

11: To make money, two things are necessary: money and time. Returns are not in our control. Those who want to become financial free much invest like their lives depend on it. For all others, try to invest for retirement at least as much you spend or as close to it as possible. So ask yourself: What is your investing growth rate (CAGR)?

12: Get a proper hobby so that you forget about money. Freefincal is, unfortunately, my hobby. Just because I write about investing, does not mean I look at my portfolio daily and tinker with it. Every statue was once a rock. If we do not know when to stop sculpting, it will become a rock again.

 

4 thoughts on “Ten Years of Mutual Fund Investing: My Journey and lessons learned

  1. Phew! And you nuggets of wisdom know no stop!
    My takeaways:-

    -> Increasing the amount you give away to help others at the same rate at which your portfolio grows will keep us grounded.

    -> Every statue was once a rock. If we do not know when to stop sculpting, it will become a rock again.

    Thanks so much for sharing your journey.

  2. Excellent read Professor, as always. I am more than glad to have a teacher like you. Your ‘hobby’ has immensely helped me understand finances, and I believe I am not the only one.

    Wish you good health, and do continue your hobby.

  3. Thanks for sharing. Wonderful lessons. I’m glad to say that with influence of Subra and you, I have been on the path for few years now – its working out well.

    Please keep sharing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *